Filter Criteria Calculator
Verifies an embankment-dam filter gradation against Sherard 1989 and NRCS NEH-633 (TR-26) criteria. Checks piping ratio, permeability ratio, uniformity coefficient, fines content, and maximum particle size in one pass. Pass/fail flag on each criterion plus a single overall verdict.
Base soil (the protected material) — gradation
Filter material — gradation
Defaults are an example for a silty-clay base (CL) with a uniformly-graded coarse sand filter. Replace with your actual gradation curves. For dispersive clays or gap-graded base materials, supplement with a No-Erosion Filter (NEF) test per NRCS NEH-633 Appendix 26B.
Detailed criteria
| Rule | Criterion | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Piping (Terzaghi-Sherard) | D15F / D85B ≤ 5 | Filter pores small enough to retain base D85 |
| Piping for fine clay base (D85B < 0.075 mm) | D15F ≤ 9·D85B | Sherard's relaxed rule for very fine cohesive base |
| Permeability | D15F / D15B ≥ 4 | Filter at least 4× more permeable than base |
| Uniformity | Cu = D60F/D10F ≤ 6 | Avoid internal instability (filter eroding itself) |
| Maximum size | D100F ≤ 76 mm (3 in) | Limit segregation during placement |
| Fines content | % passing #200 ≤ 5% | Avoid plugging the filter pores |
Worked example
Example — filter for silty-clay core
References: Sherard, J.L., Dunnigan, L.P. & Talbot, J.R. (1984). Basic Properties of Sand and Gravel Filters, ASCE J. Geotech. Eng. 110(6). Sherard, J.L. & Dunnigan, L.P. (1989). Critical Filters for Impervious Soils, ASCE J. Geotech. Eng. 115(7). USDA NRCS NEH-633, Chapter 26 (Gradation Design of Sand and Gravel Filters). USACE EM 1110-2-1901 (1993).
Common mistakes
- Applying the Terzaghi 5× rule to fine-grained base soils without checking the base category. NRCS NEH 633 Chapter 26 groups base soils by percent fines and gives fixed limits for the finer categories. For a base with 40–85% passing the No. 200 sieve, for example, the limit is D15F ≤ 0.7 mm. If the CL base in the worked example above has 40–85% fines, as a soil with D85 = 0.10 mm likely does, the proposed filter with D15F = 0.7 mm would meet that rule even though it fails the 5× ratio.
- Using the base soil’s whole gradation when it contains gravel. NEH 633 regrades the base curve on the fraction finer than the No. 4 sieve before applying the criteria.
- Allowing plastic fines in the filter. A filter with cohesive fines can hold an open crack, which defeats its purpose. Filters should be clean, non-plastic sand and gravel.
- Specifying the filter by D15 alone. A gradation band with both coarse and fine limits is needed, and the band’s own uniformity has to resist segregation during placement.
When this calculator doesn’t apply
These are criteria for granular filters protecting soil in embankment dams, levees, drains and similar structures. Geotextile filters use different criteria based on apparent opening size and soil gradation. Internally unstable base soils, dispersive clays and filters for rock foundations need specialist evaluation. Filters in dams should follow the governing agency’s criteria, such as NRCS, USACE EM 1110-2-1901, USBR or FEMA guidance.
Related tools
- Embankment seepage — gives Q the filter must drain
- Photo-sieve grain size — get D15, D50, D85 from a photo
- Riprap sizing — surface protection layer
- Slope stability FoS — verify downstream slope
- USCS soil classification
- Soil permeability k